- 1. Allegra K Women's Comfortable High Heels
- 2. Sam Edelman's Women Hazel Comfortable High Heels
- 3. Aerosole's Women Shore Thing Comfortable High Heels
- 4. Cole Haan's Women's Warner Grand Pump 55MM
- 5. Naturalizer Women's Michelle Dress Pumps
- 6. JENN ARDOR Stiletto High Heel Shoes
- 7. Susanny Women's T-Strap Dress Pumps
- 8. City Classified Comfort Medium High Heels
- 9. Marco Republic Rome Comfort Pumps
- 10. City Classified Comfort Nola Ankle Strap Block Heels
- 11. JENN ARDOR Women's Slingback Stiletto Pumps
- 12. Dunion Bernice Open Toe Strappy Stiletto
- 13. Söfft Women's Ophia Heels
- 14. Calvin Klein's Women Genoveva Pumps
- 15. Nine West Women's Ike
Do you still say “pretty hurts?” Please stop. Doggone are the days when you had to squeeze into all the pretty heels, and all that was comfortable was dull mules. Now there are tons of comfortable high heels on the market and you can confidently strut your stuff without breaking a leg. However, there’s another problem. Beyond going out to stores to test all the shoes on the rack, how do you buy shoes online and be assured of comfort? Look no further. Below is a list of the best comfortable high heels that won’t disappoint you.
The Best Comfortable High Heel
Adjustable buckled ankle straps
Allegra K’s chunky solution is the exact opposite of its name- these babies are super lightweight and designed to snugly strap on to your ankles, so you have a fluid and easy carriage.
Allegra K’s comfortable platform heels offering is designed with faux suede, so it’s not hot or harsh on the soles of your feet. An open-toe design means you can show off that killer pedicure every time you step in these shoes. Block heels on Allegra K Women’s High Chunky Heel Buckle Ankle Strap Sandals ensure that your weight is evenly spread on the platform base, and with a height lower than 4 inches, they’re all the comfort you need. You can combine them with one of the best heel inserts from our list.
Classic pointed toe pumps
3.5 inch heel height
Insole arch support and 4mm cushioning
Comfortable for long-term everyday wear
Sam Edelman’s Hazel managed to make kitty-heeled shoes that are still super comfortable, and we absolutely love them for it. These 3.5 inch high pumps are cushioned with a 4mm insole, so you don’t exactly feel like you’re walking on cement.
Another magic trick that Sam Edelman pulled on the hazel is the appropriate toe cleavage. The problem with most pumps is that they don’t leave enough space for toes to sit comfortably, but the Sam Edelman’s Women Hazel Dress Pump pulled out a trump card for that, which is why they have our number 2 spot for comfortable high heels. To meet up with the wide range of women fashion needs, the Hazel shoes come in a variety of cute patterns and colors. There’s something for every woman for every occasion, from sassy Diana to preppy Chloe.
100% man-made leather
2-inch heel height
Heel rest technology
Double-padded memory foam insole
Quick one: Women asked for comfortable high heels, and Aerosole said ‘Shore Thing.’ Then they went ahead to design Aerosole’s Women Shore Thing Dress Pump – 2-inch pumps with rounded toes and a classic, glossy upper, so you don’t have to give up style for comfort.
Aerosole’s heel rest technology is designed to shift your body weight from the balls of your feet to your heels for pure comfort all day long. That, plus double-padded insoles is a sure sign that these shoes were made to be lived in. With the diamond-patterned rubber soles on the Shore Thing, you can be sure of firm grip and traction, even on uneven surfaces. Make sure you also check our guide to the best insoles.
2 ¼ inch block heel
Round toe and adjustable ankle buckle straps
Side cutout detailing
Cole Haan’s Women’s Warner Grand Pump 55MM look like the love child of the Allegra K’s high chunky heel and Sam Edelman’s Hazel pumps. These chic shoes come in a 2-inch high block heel with a cushioned insert for maximum comfort.
The Warner Grand pumps are designed with ankle straps and buckle closure so you can adjust them to fit snugly on your feet. These shoes are also very lightweight so you can jump, step, and click without caution. Because of the round toe and the leather straps, you may want to buy half a size up to increase room for your feet and save yourself the hard leather blisters from the first few wears.
All-round foot cushioning
Naturalizer Women’s Michelle Dress Pumps are not new to the women’s shoe game, and they kept to their reputation with the Michelle pumps. At a 3-inch heel height, women can have the best of both worlds – elegance, and comfort. The Michelle pumps are high enough to look elegant but not enough to have you wobbling on your feet.
With the plush, all-shoe-round lining, and level platform, the Michelle pumps make sure that you have that confident stride all day long. You may also like to check our guide to the best flip flops for women.
4-inch stiletto heel
Comes in a variety of classy uppers
Comfortable padded insole
Great budget choice
For heels as high as 4-inches, it’s impressive that the JENN ARDOR stilettos are still super comfortable. These heels are wide enough to offer more support than traditional stilettos, so say goodbye to red, sore, blistering feet.
Another huge plus is that JENN ARDOR Stiletto High Heel Shoes are made from 100% synthetic materials, so you don’t have to worry that animals had to die just because you wanted to amp up your style. Plus, JENN ARDOR threw in a 30-day money-back guarantee, and if that’s not proof of confidence in their product, we don’t know what is.
3-inch high heels
No inner padding
Non-slip, non-skid soles
Wide enough for toe room
By default, many women think that cheap shoes often have poor quality, but Susanny went all out to prove them wrong with Susanny Women’s T-Strap Dress Pumps. We don’t really know how they did it, but what we do know is they came up with a super cute, comfy pair of heels. They might remind you of ballet pointe shoes, because of their color and cuteness, but they stand for highly comfortable high heels.
The T-strap cone-heeled shoes are designed with a decorative bow on top; which is not a detail we’re particularly excited about. However, 3-inch thick heels provide all the support and make for a very balanced movement. The round toes are wide enough for your feet to rest comfortably and the elastic, clip-on latch is an absolute delight. Note that these shoes do not have any padding so you may want to hold on to your foot gel if you’re going to be wearing them for long hours. At least we know where Susanny skimped on the bucks. Don’t forget to also check our guide to the best slides for women.
Memory foam insole padding
100% synthetic materials
Pointy toes may not make for good toe cleavage
City Classified Comfort Medium High Heels are super stylish, yet that does not mean you have to wince through wear, and that’s a big plus in our books. The shoes have a medium-low kitten heel about 3 inches high, so that makes them an easy choice for any occasion.
Closed toed heels are not always the best when it comes to comfort, yet City Classified defied that belief and lined their pumps with memory foam so that the feet do not take the toll of movement friction. And you get all these pluses for half the price of regular pumps, and twice the comfort. What’s not to love?
Almond toed with cushioned insoles
Padded foot bed for daylong comfort
Non-skid soles for added stability
Marco Republic is another brand that offers quality footwear for great prices. With their 4-inch, memory foam cushioned pumps, that reputation is preserved.
Textured soles on the Marco Republic Rome Comfort Pumps mean you have added traction on all surfaces; you won’t be falling flat on your face with these shoes. Plus, it is crafted from 100% vegan materials, so you’re slaying your style, not animals. Love these shoes? Check out our review of the best jelly shoes for our top picks.
3-inch block heels
Adjustable ankle strap
Little arch support
Memory foam insole padding
City Classified makes it back to our list of most comfortable high heels with this chic, closed toe heels. Adjustable ankle straps keep your feet from slipping out of the shoes, which is not likely because City Classified makes them true to size.
The City Classified Comfort Nola Ankle Strap Block Heels are padded for ultimate comfort, and the faux suede material is soft. Block heels and a wide base give you all the support and balance you need to strut your stuff without breaking a leg.
3.3 inch spike heel
Peep toe design
Adjustable ankle strap
100% synthetic materials
JENN ARDOR has a thing for producing versatile women shoes, and it’s all the plus that they’re so comfortable. With this second product of theirs on our list, they design a chic, peep-toed slingback that is perfect for any occasion.
At slightly above 3 inches, the slingbacks are just high enough to amp up any attire you add them, but low enough that you can comfortably walk all day in them. JENN ARDOR Women’s Slingback Stiletto Pumps are made of entirely synthetic, breathable material and the peep toe is great for more ventilation. It also means that this pair is a lifesaver for wide feet. If your new shoes are feeling tight, check out our shoe stretchers review.
3.5 inch stiletto heels
Sexy, trendy strap design
Open toed heels for maximum comfort
Adjustable ankle strap
Dunion’s offer a fiercely trendy style for all the comfort you still get. These 3.5-inch heels have a stylish, strappy design that is bound to amp your style and have heads turning while you strut.
Rubber soles on the Dunion Bernice Open Toe Strappy Stiletto ensure that the said strut is not interrupted by a skid and fall, and the faux leather is soft, so the shoes are fine for all-day wear. The footbed and stiletto heels are double padded with memory foam to offer ultimate balance and stability while walking. Check out our buying guide for best pole dance shoes.
2 ¾ inch block heels
Vintage, lasercut leather details
Textured soles for balance
If you cannot tell from their name, Söfft makes shoes so comfortable, they had to have two ‘F’s for emphasis. They may be on the high side, but the Söfft Women’s Ophia Heels deliver so much on style and comfort that you probably wouldn’t mind.
If boho cool is your style, then you’d love the wood grain details on Sofft’s design. Adjustable ankle straps mean it slips on and off in a blink, and the peep toes are all the space you need for your toes to breathe. The textured heels give you balance for that spring in your walk, and at inky 2 ¾ Inches high, you could be walking all day in these shoes. Our selection of the best shoes for Zumba offers more great footwear so check it out.
2-inch block heels
Low arch support
Pre-installed gel inserts
Luxury brand Calvin Klein delivers a 2-inch block heel as their solution for uncomfortable heels.
The Calvin Klein’s Women Genoveva Pumps are flexible and great for extended wear. They also come with Calvin Klein’s signature gel pod inserts for ultra-comfort and support, so you don’t have to worry about blisters or sore feet. Plus, you can save the bucks on buying inserts if they don’t fit. Slip-resistant and weather-proof outsoles provide shock absorption with every step.
2-inch block heel
Medium arch support
Inner footbed padding
Last on our list, but in no way, the least, is Nine West Women’s IKE 2-inch block heels. These sophisticated shoes are bound to up your style in an instant, without passing up on comfort. The inner soles are lightly padded to ease the pressure on your footbeds from everyday wear.
The leather upper is gentle on the feet, but it may take a few weeks of wear to break it in and reduce the friction on your feet. Alternatively, use gel inserts for the first few wears. The traction on these shows are great and they can be paired with just about any outfit. If you need sports shoes, check out our guide to the best trail running shoes for women.
Best Comfortable High Heels Buying Guide
How We Chose Our Selection Of The Best Comfortable High Heels
High heels are women's wardrobe staples, and choices/preferences vary across different style orientations and needs. So, we had to leave this one to the women. Picking from a range of renowned brands, we let them have a field day strutting in select pairs of high heels, relying on their judgment for ranking based on the requirements below. Also, we rigorously complied other customer reviews on the brand, to be 100% objective with our verdicts, because we are well aware of the importance of picking out your bridal wedding shoes if you opt for a high hell model. In this review, each pair of high heels that we tested was only as good as:
Brand - We selected from a range of renowned brands that have been trusted in the shoemaking game for long. However, each brand was only as good as the value and comfort they were offering with each pair of shoes.
Price - We realize that as much as women do not want to break a leg in their favorite pair of comfy shoes, they also do not want to break the bank. We made sure that each pair featured was offering premium value for the prices stated.
Shoe prices vary across the different brands, so there is something for everyone - from budget range to luxury range.
Reviews - Apart from price and brands, we depended on the verdict of countless customer reviews before picking the choices that made it to our list. Nobody's opinion was greater than that of the people who have worn and had real-life experiences with all of the featured shoes.
Features To Look For In Comfortable High Heels
Comfort - Not to sound obvious, but the first feature to look out for when shopping for comfortable high heels is comfort (duh). Whether you're shopping physically or online, ensure that you make size and height choices that would give you the maximum comfort when you're wearing shoes. Pretty shoes don't count for much when you can't even wear them because they'll give you hellish blisters.
Test for toe space and cleavage, and make sure to go for breathable materials to avoid stinking up your shoes. Also, it is best to go for shoes with insole lining, and flat bases are recommended so that your weight is evenly spread on the shoe surface area. To enhance the comfort of your high heels we recommend you best heel grips currently available in the market.
Style - Nobody said anything about giving up style for comfort, so do make sure that your shoes are as stylish as they are comfortable. Pick out trendy designs that don't hurt, literally, and do all the tests to make sure that you're not passing up comfort for style, either.
Heel height - Apart from being medically inadvisable, extra high heels can get uncomfortable pretty fast. It is safer to go for 4-inch heels max and only those that provide support and stability when you walk.