7 Best Saddle Shoes (Review) In 2022
Saddle shoes have been all the rave for over 90 years now. They were originally designed for indoor sports, offering much-needed comfort and support for the feet. Nowadays, they are like every other trending fashion item, with many different styles on offer. So, when choosing the best saddle shoes, it’s worth noting that you’ll probably be spending lots of hours in your shoes, hence why it’s a recipe for foot disaster to choose a shoe that doesn’t satisfy your needs. To this end, this well-curated list of the best saddle shoes on the market will help.
The Best Saddle Shoe
1. Eastland Women’s Sadie Oxford
All-leather design upper
Rubber made outsole
Adjustable secure lace
The makers of this one have been at it for 60 years. They’ve been making shoes that stand the test of pressure and time and the Eastland Women’s Sadie Oxford is no exception. The quality begins with the upper which is 100 percent durable leather with a two-color design and brogue finish. For comfortable wear, the insoles are foamy and guaranteed to give your feet a comfy welcome anytime you slip in. In terms of wearability, Eastland Oxfords have a low cut shaft with adjustable laces. Furthermore, the brown rubber sole doesn’t just support the user but contributes to the overall beautiful outlook of the shoes.
If you like flat shoes, these oxfords have heels but they are less than an inch so you can totally swing it without worrying about the painful arch. Overall, the shoes are comfortable and lightweight, though they might run a bit small; but that’s not a big deal, simply order a size higher than what’s stated on the conversion chart. Furthermore, the shoes come in black and white only and can be worn with dress pants, jeans, shorts, and even gowns. You’ll certainly gather a lot of attention when you swing this for the first time.
Low shaft delivers easy wearability
Wider feet design available
Size runs small
Rubber sole is prone to slipping
Lacing is a hassle
2. Cole Haan Men’s Oxford
Rubber pods heel support
Cole Haan Men’s Oxford brings this one in for anyone who enjoys sporting a casual look, with a little bit of class. The Cool Haan Oxford further comes in five tastefully finished designs. If you are a lover of fine shoes, you’ll probably find yourself picking all of them at a go, if you can afford it, as they are all excellent designs. This Oxford equally combines a carefully engineered knit upper and a chestnut brown brogue leather. Now add the sporty outsole which gives this footwear its complete balanced look of class and simplicity. Owing to the fact that the sole is made of soft, durable rubber material, you’ll love how you feel when you walk in these shoes.
The impact absorbing effect of the sole practically hugs your heel and arch. That’s not all; the heels are further furnished with rubber support pods to deliver the traction as you walk in them. Even more, the shoe is very well cushioned for super comfort. You’ll like that the upper material is quite flexible and breathable, so your feet won’t get any bruises or rashes. Altogether, this pair of shoes is guaranteed to turn heads and people will want to know where you got them. Pair it with denim, khaki, and chinos, you’ll love how it blends in easily. It’s not every day you get a saddle shoe with a sporty side, though the price is on the steep side, you’ll be glad you made the purchase.
Heel support delivers traction
Knit upper material is breathable
Allows free movement
A bit pricey
The shoe appears a bit long
Quality control is an issue
3. U-lite Women’s Wingtip Oxford Shoes
Durable cow-hide leather
Rubber made sole
Low cut shaft
U-lite combines high-quality leather material and a tasteful finish in this oxford women’s shoes. You can’t help but notice how durable and sturdy the U-lite Women’s Wingtip Oxford Shoes prove to be, it’s amazing. One look and you’ll want to slip into one of these right away. In the area of versatility, this shoe checks out well. Swing it with denim, dress pants, or your office wear and it’ll blend right in. It further features a brown and blue cowhide leather upper with a durable leather lining and comfortable footbed.
What’s more, the low cut design combined with lace-up vamp makes wearability easy peasy. And although you’ll need to tie and untie it, the flexible lace makes it easy. On top of this, the U-lite wingtip is equally supported by a rubber sole below with slightly elevated heels that’ll make you stand a few inches tall. All in all, the U-lite Women’s Wingtip Oxford Shoes come in 9 different colors, and they are suitable for both winters or summer. What’s more, you’ll equally love how light the shoes are for easy movement.
Comfortable to wear
It is versatile
Available in many colors
Maybe initially be hard
Gives off a chemical odor
Slippery rubber sole
4. Ellie Shoes Women’s 105-SD Oxford
Tough polyurethane material craft
Synthetic material engineered solely
Fairly high heels
If you are a fan of old school design, Ellie Shoes Women’s 105-SD Oxford is a clear indicator of why these shoes were so popular. Aside from the tending status they carried at the time, they were incredibly comfortable shoes. Women wore them for long hours even to the disco. So you can bet your left leg that the women’s 105-SD Oxford doesn’t come short in the department of comfort either.
The shoe features an all-polyurethane material upper with a beautiful white design and there’s also a black overlay that runs through the lace area with perforations for people who love brogues. What’s more, the matte finish gives it an even better outlook, which is great for people who don’t like their shoes looking all that glossy. The inner here is furnished with light padding which offers more room for bigger feet and also allows you to swing in extra footbeds for customized comfort.
Furthermore, the soles are made out of tough synthetic material that’ll withstand pressure from walking over time while the heels equally measure a quarter above an inch. It might seem a little high for ladies who like their shoes flat but if you don’t mind the extra height you’ll gain as you walk tall in this Ellie’s shoe craft, then this is right for you.
You can wear them with nice fancy pants, gowns, long or short skirts. It’s a versatile pair of footwear and it comes in affordable too. even better, it comes in 2 other designs that scream all shades and styles, a white/pink blend, and a pink/ black overlay.
Available in a multicolored design
Roomy to accommodate insoles
Heels make noise on non-carpet floors
Heels may feel too high
The hassle of untying/ tying lace
5. Ferro Aldo Arthur MFA139001D Men’s Wingtip
Durable synthetic leather-like material
If you are a Wingtip shoes lover then the Ferro Aldo Arthur MFA139001D Men’s Wingtip will catch your fancy. This traditional saddle shoe presents a fantastic blend between formal and casual, so this isn’t just a tap shoe for fancy suits and dance shows. If you take a swing with this bad boy in black jeans, you’ll definitely turn a couple of heads down the block. What’s more, the Ferro Aldo wingtip features the classic perforation which is not just functional, but aesthetically pleasing. You’ll also love the pointed toe-cap and the extension that runs the entire length of the shoes. And even though it’s made out of durable synthetic leather, if you give it a decent polishing you’ll mistake it for pure leather. The material is highly durable and fairly flexible to accommodate movement of your toes and feet. You won’t be getting any blisters with this one.
Even more, the inner lining of the shoes is furnished with tender fabric engineered to make your feet comfortable even for a long time wearing them. On top of this, the cool classic black and white design is ideal for an all-white or black suit event and you’ll equally love the brown and white design as it’s a perfect blend for people who like to roll in beige colored chinos.
That said, the shoes run a little larger, so you might want to consider that when placing your order. Furthermore, at first glance, it looks a little bulky but surprisingly it doesn’t feel heavy at all. A little heads up, if you’ve got a very sensitive nose, the shoes come with a heavy odor of the new synthetic/leather material. It’s also worth noting that it may arrive with a bit of a smell, but it’s just the smell of new synthetic material, it’ll disappear after a while. In terms of price, it is quite affordable and the manufacturer threw in an open 30-day window to return the shoes if you are not so psyched about it.
Room for feet movement
Tender inner lining
Shoes run large that Stated size
Strong chemical odor
Heels may be too tall for some
6. G.H. Bass & Co. Men’s Proctor Oxford
Flexible leather suede
Durable soft rubber sole
Soft padded insole
This is one of those shoes that checks out in terms of simplicity and exquisite finish. If you are a lover of fine suede footwear that you can gear-up with denim or chinos, this G.H Bass & Co. Men’s Proctor Oxford will catch your attention at first glance. The Men’s Proctor Oxford features a brown suede leather upper finish with an incredibly soft feel that offers some flexibility. Another thing you’ll notice immediately about these shoes is the comfort that’ll welcome your feet as you slip in. Additionally, you’ll also notice that there’s no slight pain which some shoes present in the first couple of years before they expand. All thanks to the rubber insole and the flexible suede leather material.
What’s more, it’s a low cut shaft combined with an easy to adjust lace, so you’re guaranteed it’s easy to put on and pull-off. The white color of the shoelace will also catch your eye as it presents a beautiful blend with the white stitch that runs through the entire length of the suede material. Furthermore, this proctor Oxford comes in a rounded-toe design, that offers extra strength furnished to the tip of the shoes. If you accidentally run into a wall or huge rock, your toes won’t feel the hit.
Furthermore, the sole is made out of soft durable rubber that supports your weight and absorbs impact with every step. For those that want to switch their style up a bit, the design comes in another shade of brown. The price is a little steep, but you’ll be happy you spent it.
It is comfortable
Equipped with adjustable lace
Has a soft rubber sole
May run large
The front appears too long
A bit pricey
7. Florsheim Kid’s Kennett Jr Ss-K
Low cut shaft
Give your kid the classic exquisite look of a true gentleman with the Florsheim Kid’s Kennett Jr Ss-K. The shoe itself features an all-leather sandy brown color upper with a chocolate brown overlay finished with a perforated brogue. What’s more, the Kennett Jr Ss-K is further equipped with an adjustable lace to promote easy access to the feet. whilst the design offers a low cut shaft; so there’ll be no struggling to slip-in or out. Even more, the upper sits on an orange-colored sole made out of durable rubber with a hint of blue. The heels are less than an inch high, so these are almost flat and won’t cause any pain. You’ll also like the fact that the shoes are sure to withstand pressure from many outings.
Even better is the fact that it sits on the versatile side with its simple yet elegant design and you’ll also love that your kids can swing it with jeans, chinos, or formal wear, like a suit – if you’ve got a kid that likes to roll in a more mature way. Additionally, the shoes are made for a wide age range so anyone from preschoolers to pre-teens can rock them. So, if you’ve got more than one kid within that age range, there are enough sizes to go round. Perhaps you are on the hunt for a gift and don’t know what to get your son or nephew just yet? Is so, just try these out for either his birthday or Christmas.
It’s easy to wear
Comes in a lightweight design
The laces are problematic
Not available in multiple colors
Requires different shades of polish
Saddle Shoe Buying Guide
Features To Look For In Best Saddle Shoes
Comfort - Comfort is the most important factor when on the hunt for a saddle shoe or any other kind of shoe. This sounds like a cliché but you’d be surprised that people compromise this important factor for the secondary needs in a shoe such as color, style, etc. This is quite common especially when a new design just hits the market. Because users know a specific type of color or style, they make their comfort secondary. Here are a couple more things to look out for.
Cushioning - The insides of your shoes need to have a cushioning material to support your feet. This may be fabric or synthetic cushioning. In addition, padding must be in a place where your feet land on. This must also be a cushioned material.
Right Fitting - Your shoe should not be too small. While you may find a way to get your feet inside a significantly small pair of shoes to get that perfect smart look, consider whether you’ll be able to walk, stand, dance, or run in them. It must also not be too large, as it may fall off or affect the way you walk.
Color - While the color of your Oxfords may not affect your physical comfort in any way, it’s a factor to consider as it will motivate you to wear your shoes more. Since Saddle shoes can sometimes come in a blend of two different colors try to opt for a color blend that fits the color of your pants, denim, gown, etc especially when you are not shopping for new clothes to match your new shoes.
Design - This is also an important factor that largely rests on what you need your shoes for. If you want a saddle or Oxford shoes for casual needs such as outings with friends, movies, clubs, it's okay to choose a design that screams funky. However, if your needs are official, you'll want a pair of Oxfords that you can easily swing to work without attracting the attention of HR for dressing inappropriately. Then you need to look out for a leather crafted upper with a color that doesn’t scream “lets a party”.
Material - This is another very important factor to consider as you buy your saddle shoes. Manufacturers engineer their shoes using different materials such as leather, synthetic, polyurethane, etc. Sometimes it can be a mixture of materials. Irrespective of the material used in constructing the shoes, you should opt for a material that’s flexible. Flexible material will give room for you to wiggle your toes and won’t press hard against your feet. This will further promote easy movement. In addition, it will make it easy to stand in them for a longer period.
A material that's a bit too stiff can cause discomfort and pain. While this may sometimes occur with new shoes that haven't been subjected to any pressure, it's expected to go away after wearing them a couple of times. Furthermore, in terms of maintenance, you should consider an Oxford so you’ll find the material easy to clean or polish.
Durability - It’s easy to opt for a poorly crafted shoe if you are on a tight budget. It’s also easy to pay good money for shoes crafted out of material that is not durable if you have no idea what you are looking for. 100% high-quality leather designed uppers are usually durable and withstand the elements of weather both in summer and winter. Other materials are also durable such as fabric or a combination of materials. If your budget is flexible enough, look out for durable leather mounted on equally durable rubber or leather.
Sole - Any shoe including a saddle or Oxford that will give you good support should have a thick sole. This should be thick enough to absorb shock as you move so that your feet don't sink-in or return impact to you thereby causing pain. Most saddle shoes are made with rubber or leather soles. Without a single doubt both present advantages with respect to durability and support, but also have disadvantages.
Leather soles are very strong even stronger than rubber but they are more rigid. A rubber sole on the other hand offers more flexibility and grip. Depending on the manufacturer, either a quality rubber or leather sole will last longer and give the right support. It's a good idea to avoid soles made out of hard plastic, with no flexibility as they break easily and cause pain.
Outsole - The outsole is sometimes used interchangeably with the sole as they are in fact the same unit. The sole as a whole contains the outsole which is the bottom of the outermost part of the sole which makes direct contact with the floor or ground. Manufacturers make outsoles using different varieties of materials such as leather and rubber. You should look out for an outsole that fits your needs.
For instance, if you are a professional dancer, you will of course prefer shoes with smooth finishing outsoles that will aid your dancing moves and support you on the dance floor. On the other hand, if you work in a water bottling factory where you are exposed to an environment where the floors are a potential hazard, you may require an outsole that provides slip-proof features. Generally, lots of saddle shoes have soles made of durable rubber, and they last longer.
Style - Style is a factor dependent on individual choice. If you like to dial it down a bit more often, this may determine the kind of saddle shoe you’ll choose. On the other hand, if you like to appear formal, even when you don’t have an 8-5 desk job, this will also determine your choice of color.